Practicing Optimism in a Crappy World


After my last couple of posts, several people said they appreciate my optimism—a trait that is clearly in short supply these days. As I don’t think I’m either ostrich or Pollyanna, and I’ve done plenty of ranting and yelling at the images on the TV news and on my often too-smart-by-half phone, I’ve been exploring the source of the hopefulness that I’ve been conveying to you.

I think that the mindfulness meditation I’ve been practicing for more than a year now has finally reached fruition, and I’d like to share some of my discoveries and resources.

I’ve been meditating with help from various gurus offering guided imagery through CDs and phone downloads for quite some time, and last Fall I took an 8-week course on Mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR), a program developed by Jon Kabat-Zinn, PhD, at the University of Massachusetts Medical School. I took the course near my home; it’s available in many areas and involves walking, sitting, and standing meditations, gentle yoga, body scans—with your mind, not technology—and the like.

Kabat-Zinn also coined the term “mindfulness,” which stems from early Buddhism, calling it “the awareness that emerges through paying attention on purpose, in the present moment, and non-judgmentally, to the unfolding of experience moment by moment.” The emphasis is on concentrating on the rhythm of your breath to focus your mind.

Kabat-Zinn’s program has actually been associated with positive changes in the brain: an article in Psychiatric Res (2011 Jan 30;191(1):36-43, which for some reason won’t hyperlink) noted “changes in gray matter concentration in brain regions involved in learning and memory processes, emotion regulation, self-referential processing, and perspective-taking.”

Who wouldn’t want that?  But for the longest time, though I was a diligent student and meditated daily, I felt I wasn’t getting the full benefit. I was “stuck,” allowing the same dopey stories—sometimes annoying, sometimes worrisome—to race around in my brain. And my “inner critic” wouldn’t let me get away for a minute with that non-judgmental stuff Kabat-Zinn talks about. What’s so hard about this? I’d berate myself. I’ve been doing it forever. Why can’t I master it?

Some time ago, I had the opportunity to speak with Sharon Salzberg, a well-known and beloved teacher and a founder of the highly acclaimed Insight Meditation Society in Barre, Massachusetts. Salzberg suggests dealing with the inner critic by giving it a name or persona.

Hers is Lucy, the Peanuts character who told Charlie Brown: “The problem with you is that you’re you.” When she has negative feelings about herself, she acknowledges them by thinking, “Hi, Lucy,” or “Chill it, Lucy,” in a friendly manner.

I’ve adopted my own Lucy, and finally, finally, I realize I’m spending more time living in the moment. Granted, there are some pretty scary moments all around us these days, but once you don’t dwell on them and continue to replay them, they lose their heft.

The whole point, which I’ve known for some time but only just become able to internalize, is that if you accept these feelings, thoughts, and fears and don’t fight them, knowing they’re transitory, they pass fairly quickly. You simply move on.

I am bolstered by imagery like that of the man standing outside his house, burdened by two heavy suitcases. One contains “regrets”; the other holds “worries.” First he drops one; then the other. His step is considerably lighter as he walks away.

I am also bolstered by the oft-repeated quotation attributed to Mark Twain: “I’ve lived a long and difficult life filled with so many misfortunes—most of which never happened.”

Tara Brach, one of my favorite mindfulness gurus, encourages smiling. In one of her talks, she says, “Smiling affects areas of the brain associated with happiness; it can’t cause happiness, but it can tip you in that direction.” If you want to try it, begin by sensing a smile around your eyes, then your mouth, your heart, and then sense and feel that smile throughout your body.

I find Brach’s talks so helpful that I listen to them repeatedly. One of them, “Meditation: The Radical Acceptance of Pain,” has on occasion freed me from a migraine headache without medication. The talk is less than 12 minutes long, and I recommend that anyone suffering from pain locate it via Google and listen to it—maybe even twice. There’s nothing like relieving one’s pain to open a path to optimism.

Mindfulness recently got a nod from Bill Gates in The New York Times Book Review (September 9). Reviewing the new book 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, Gates says the author insists “that life in the 21st century demands mindfulness—getting to know ourselves better and seeing how we contribute to the suffering in our own lives.”

Acknowledging that this idea is “easy to mock,” Gates writes: “As someone who’s taking a course on mindfulness and meditation, I found it compelling.”

Though mindfulness is helpful to the individual, its proponents see its widespread practice as beneficial to the larger society. Emphasis is placed on the concept of lovingkindness. As Salzberg has said: “Lovingkindness and compassion are the opposites of fear.”

Another favorite guru, Jack Kornfield, speaks of the importance of equanimity, “the ability to meet all experience with a balanced mind.” Acknowledging that sometimes situations demand a strong response, he asserts that even such a response can be done with equanimity.

Equanimity arises from “living with a deep understanding of the passing of all things,” and leads to a peaceful heart. “With a peaceful heart, you can see clearly and respond wisely.”

The best leaders, he says, “combine strength and wisdom with a steady and peaceful heart.”  And so I say, optimistically: If enough of us follow this path–and if we elect leaders who meet that definition–perhaps we can make the world a little less crappy.

It’s been quite a journey for me to reach this point, and I’ll readily acknowledge there are times when reality’s bite makes me feel optimism is kind of nutty. But then I breathe, smile, and the shadow passes. We really don’t have to live in anger and fear.

Perhaps you’ll join me? Have you tried mindfulness? Are you tempted? As always, I’m eager for your thoughts. And even if you don’t care to comment, if you like this or any of my other posts, please feel free to share and/or click on “like.”

I’ll close by echoing Kornfield’s message: May you–may we all–live with a peaceful heart.


23 thoughts on “Practicing Optimism in a Crappy World

  1. So great..If only we could be present all the time. I find that as I get older the CD in my brain seems to be less consuming. When I am listening to patients I sometimes have to work hard at just being there and not just jumping in with the next question or thought. Another wonderful blog is called Brain Pickings, is free and usually comes on Sundays…very thought stimulating and does get you away from the reality of our day to day existence..Much love, Noah


    1. Hi, Noah–

      I’m willing to bet that your patients are blissfully unaware that the good Dr. Finkel’s brain CD has skipped even a little bit! But it’s true that being present takes some work and time. And thanks for the recommendation about Brain Pickings, which definitely seems to be worth a good look.




  2. How lovely. I also agree it’s pointless to fear something or anger your heart about something since that qenergy that one used should Be channeled to other better directions to view life.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you! I’m so glad you found your way here. I thought of you especially with regard to Sharon Salzberg’s approach to the inner critic, which really resonates with me. Let’s stay connected, OK?



  3. Love the idea of walking lighter. And I’m so glad you pointed out that it takes a while to feel the impact of a meditative practice. Why is it that we experience the crappy stuff in life so quickly and resolutely, but to make a positive change takes time? Patience and faith, too, which have never been my strong suits.

    Once, a while back, I was in therapy. Actually, I saw a few therapists through the years, until I found a really good match for my personality. Such a smart woman — not terribly nice, but wise, and she had a brisk practice to show for it. Her waiting room had a reasonably good-sized volume of Mark Twain letters. While I waited, I read and loved every word. I even laughed, which is not something that normally happens in a therapist’s waiting room. Sometimes I think I got as much out of Twain as I did the therapy. When I finished the book, I quit going.

    Thank you for your writing, Annie. No, really. Your post is a wakeup call: time to pursue a more mindful, meaningful, calm frame of mind. Honestly, I have a hard time imagining that it’s possible, but you give me hope. It would just be so liberating to be free from worry. That’s worth the plunge.


    1. Denise,

      I’m grateful to you for sharing your honest post. Yes, the mindfulness takes time and effort, and even practitioners who’ve gone on months-long retreats for years will report periods when they just don’t feel it all comes together, but it’s definitely worth staying with it. To me, the inner critic matter was huge, and while my Lucy hasn’t disappeared, she’s a far less formidable presence than she had been.

      Why do we experience the crappy stuff so quickly and resolutely? That seems to go back to our being hard-wired for fight/flight/freeze. These are deeply held reactions that we really have to work to modify/harness. And we get plenty of reinforcement toward the negative, but much less toward the positive. That’s why mindfulness is such a powerful mode of living.

      Though you praise your therapist’s wisdom, I can understand why you didn’t want to stay with someone who wasn’t terribly nice. To me, empathy is essential to good therapy–actually, any good communication–and from your description, I’m not sure that therapist exuded much of it.

      I plan to put Mark Twain’s letters on my reading list.

      Best of luck with your mindfulness. I really encourage obtaining resources for guided meditations and/or good classes or groups. It’s tough to just sit there all be yourself.

      And I’m so glad you found the post helpful. Please keep your comments coming.



  4. Hi Annie. What is your leaning as far as the Course in Miracles lady running to be the Democratic nominee for president?

    Smiling and breathing and body scanning are good. And I might check out one fella you mentioned. It’s good you’ve found help.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You mean Marianne Williamson, I assume? I don’t consider her a serious candidate. I think she sometimes makes good points but has had to walk back some of her earlier more far-out pronouncements about vaccinations and anti-depressants. “I’m not anti-science,” she said, claiming she supports medications that aren’t made by profit-making drug companies. That doesn’t leave us with much. She’s probably making a fortune out of the publicity she’s garnering from this campaign, but if she actually helps people, which she seems to do, that’s great. Not my cup of tea.


      1. I think she adds a little bit, like Enslee added (even though he’s stepped away now). He is a more serious candidate, and could be a vice president or cabinet member or such. I was introduced to the Course in Miracles long ago and decided it wasn’t my cup of tea. When I listened to her speak of it on YouTube (from however many years ago), she made it sound better. She made something work for her.

        Liked by 1 person

  5. I’ve been an off and on meditator for about 40 years. It certainly brings balance to life and when I am away from it I find myself more irritated with world events. I was a practicing Catholic and preferred the monastic tradition. I think it was a gigantic mistake to do away with Latin in the 60’s. I read a lot of St. John of the Cross, Thomas Merton and John Main. The latter two trying to blend western Catholic meditation with eastern methods. I actually took a two years yoga teaching course (Kundalini) in my thirties and went to a number of retreats but life got in the way. Interesting post Annie. As a side note I discovered this post by accident and it seems some of your posts are not making it into my in box even though WordPress still states that I am following you? Technology. I ask you.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Technology. Yes. I’ve been dealing, today, with my technology. Remember having to jigger an antenna for a television? I have to jigger my charging connection. This has happened before, with a previous item of this brand. I thought maybe it was something about what I was doing… so I changed my behaviour. Now I’m convinced they have this weakness in the design so that one will “have to” buy new again.

      I know that’s a different aspect of technology, Len. I “get” what you mentioned too.

      Deep breaths. 😀


    2. That’s so interesting, Len. As to your not get my posts, this one was a reblog from a year ago, and you joined me seven months ago. My most recent post was “My Presidential Nominee Wish List.” Did you get that? I have had a few other people telling me they don’t get email notifications, though.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s